Association Internationale des Hautes Juridictions Administratives
International Association of Supreme Administrative Jurisdictions

Interviews with the magistrates

Nomena Fandresena Barimahefasoa, magistrate at the Council of State of Madagascar and participant to the 2026 exchange program

Magistrate at the Council of State of Madagascar, she took part to the 2026 magistrates’ exchange program and did a two weeks internship at the Administrative Court of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg from September 14 to September 25.

Her internship report can be downloaded here.

Why did you want to participate in the exchange program organized by the Association?

There are two main reasons behind this participation. The first is to broaden my understanding of administrative justice. Given that judicial systems are increasingly drawing inspiration from one another, direct observation of a foreign court provides valuable insight. Discovering a different system – with its own working methods, organisation, drafting practices and legal culture – enables us to take a step back from our day-to-day practice and to question which aspects of our own system stem from habit rather than necessity.

The second is the study of the impact of European law on national justice. In this respect, Luxembourg offers a prime setting for observation: administrative judges there apply domestic law whilst taking into account the requirements of European Union law. This overlap between the national legal order and the European legal order does not exist in African law. The aim was therefore to understand how a national judge deals with a superior source of law originating from another level, and how this influence gradually transforms the rules, reasoning and checks and balances applied.

Finally, this approach was part of a comparative perspective. The study of the role of European law in Luxembourg enables us to draw a parallel with the development of administrative law in Madagascar, to better assess the progress already made, and to inform the discussion on possible avenues for this development, in the face of external influences and the growing expectations of litigants.


What did you learn from your stay at the Administrative Court of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg?

Three key lessons emerge from this experience. Firstly, the efficiency of the Court, which operates with a reduced staff of just seven judges. This condensed organisation does not prevent cases from being dealt rigorously. It demonstrates that the quality of justice depends as much on the organisation of work, the allocation of tasks and the commitment of the judges as it does on the size of the workforce. This lesson is of particular interest to courts facing a high volume of litigation with limited resources.

Secondly, the efforts made to ensure that judgments are made accessible to the public. Making decisions available enhances the transparency and accessibility of administrative justice. It enables litigants, lawyers, the administration and academics to understand the Court’s position, contributes to legal certainty and the predictability of case-law, and enhances public confidence in the institution.

Finally, the Court’s commitment to developing administrative law through case law. Case law takes account of society’s aspirations and the diversity of matters brought before the Court, whether they concern traditional litigation or more recent fields. It is therefore dynamic in nature, adapted to contemporary realities. As administrative law is largely derived from case law, this dialogue with society appears essential to its development.

Can you tell us something that particularly caught your attention in the functioning, the organization or the activity of the Court?

Two distinctive features of the Luxembourg system caught my attention: the absence of a public prosecutor and the fact that the Court has no advisory role. Litigation proceeds without a public prosecutor, which differs from the dynamics of the preliminary investigation and deliberations in systems where this role exists, notably that of Madagascar. Furthermore, the Administrative Court has no advisory functions. This role is exclusively reserved for the Luxembourg Council of State, thereby establishing a clear separation between judicial and advisory functions. This organisational structure provides a highly instructive point of comparison for systems which, like that of Madagascar, combine these functions within a single institution.

Outside the Court, the programme of visits was at once tourist-oriented, cultural and judicial in nature. At the institutional level, it included visits to the EFTA Court, the Benelux Court, the Council of State, the Court of Justice of the European Union and the Cité judiciaire. These visits provided an insight into the structure of the courts based in Luxembourg and how they relate to the national, European and regional legal systems. From a cultural and tourist perspective, the programme included visits to the Philharmonie, Vianden Castle, the city centre and the Grund district. This trip was an unforgettable personal and professional experience.

Dr Mohamed Ismail, judge of the Council of State of Egypt and participant in the exchange program in 2021

Dr Mohamed Ismail is a member of the Council of State of Egypt. He participated in the exchange program in 2021 and did a two-week internship at the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic.

Dr Ismail's report can be downloaded here.

Why did you want to participate in the exchange program organized by the Association?

Due to the phenomenon of legal globalization, the exchange of global judicial principles between various legal cultures has become a fundamental factor behind the enhancement and creation of new judicial approaches in the Egyptian Supreme Administrative Court. During my thirty years at the Egyptian Conseil d’État, I have seen upfront the importance of sharing legal views transnationally, and its benefits towards the development of legal doctrine. Given that administrative law principles are not codified in written legislation, inspiration can be drawn from international applications of administrative laws. Furthermore, considering Egypt’s role in shaping Arab legal principles and legislation, the exchange program would have given insight into ways in which international principles could be suited for application in Middle Eastern jurisdictions.

What did you learn from your stay in the Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic?

The Supreme Administrative Court of the Czech Republic is one of the pre-eminent judicial bodies on the European continent. During my time at the Court, throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, the Court exercised its judicial review upon the general precautionary measures issued by the administrative bodies for the fight against the spread of the new Coronavirus. The approach of the Court in many cases was unique, whereby they sought to create a sensible balance between individual liberties on one hand and public health constraints on the other. Most constitutions of the world grant the administration extraordinary powers if there are extraordinary circumstances that states are facing. For instance, Article (16) of the French Constitution (October 4, 1958) deals clearly with powers granted to the administration during any given state of emergency. Arab constitutions deal similarly with the matter. During my time at the Supreme Administrative Court, it was increasingly insightful how the court employed principles which kept the balance between individual liberties and common welfare.

Can you tell us something that particularly caught your attention in the functioning, the organization or the activity of the Court?

The structure of the administrative judiciary of the Supreme Administrative Court in the Czech Republic is unique. I was particularly impressed with the Documentation and Research Department at the Court, which plays an indispensable role in research and case preparation. The department worked on the translation of different judgments from different countries to make use of global trends. I was also interested in seeing the role of judicial clerks, and their efforts to assist judges in the issuance of judgments. Finally, the composition of the court was of particular interest to me. The Court appoints judges from eminent university professors, distinguished lawyers, efficient judicial clerks, and lower court judges. This process is very particular as it maintains diversification in legal backgrounds which enriches the quality and fabric of the court. 

I would like to note that the cultural part of the visit was very rich. I visited Prague Opera to attend the famous show of the Marriage of Figaro ‘Le nozze di Figaro’. I also visited the National Museum complex in Prague. I had one long day trip to Vienna where I visited the House of Mozart, the House of Music Museum and Albertina Museum.

© AIHJA - IASAJ Copyright

2026